Skip to content
Aldric & Herbi

The Fight Jon Jones Should Have Lost? One of the Judges Is Insane

December 18, 20251:06:0810 130 views on YouTube261 likes
The Fight Jon Jones Should Have Lost? One of the Judges Is Insane

Jones-Reyes UFC 247 re-scored round by round, with the crazy story of judge Joe Solis.

Key facts
  • Show : Aldric & Herbi of Jab Life, aired on December 18, 2025, 1:06:08.
  • People discussed : Jon Jones, Dominick Reyes, Joe Rogan, Manon Fiorot, Valentina Shevchenko, Jiří Procházka, Daniel Cormier, Thiago Santos, Alexander Volkanovski.
  • Topics : MMA judging, Jones-Reyes, Texas rules, Joe Solis, athletic commissions, we re-scored.
  • Source : transcript of the show, 10 130 views on YouTube.

What is said in the show

Alexandre Herbinet and Aldric Cassata re-score the fight between Jon Jones and Dominick Reyes at UFC 247, in February 2020 in Houston. They recall the context: Jones at 32, 25-1, his last fight at light heavyweight, third defense of his second reign. Reyes, 12-0, is presented as a serious challenger. The three judges gave a unanimous decision to Jones, but 80% of fans and 14 out of 21 media outlets saw Reyes as the winner. The show details the Texas athletic rules, which have not adopted the modern unified criteria and place defense, aggression, and octagon control on the same level as striking. Judge Joe Solis, who turned in a 49-46 scorecard for Jones, had only officiated seven UFC fights, all in Texas. The two hosts analyze each round: the first three are awarded to Reyes, the fourth and fifth to Jones. Their final verdict is 48-47 Reyes under the unified rules, and they explain why Solis may have reasoned differently under the Texas criteria.

Chapters

  • 0:00Intro
  • 1:05Context around the Jones-Reyes fight
  • 4:00The judges' scores and the fans' scores
  • 7:25Alert craziness: a fight in Texas, why it changes things
  • 15:45Joe Solis, the crazy story of a judge who had no business being there
  • 25:50Analysis of round 1
  • 29:45Analysis of round 2
  • 37:35Analysis of round 3
  • 46:55Analysis of round 4
  • 51:45Analysis of round 5
  • 1:03:40Our final verdict: who gets the win?

Questions raised in the show

Our final verdict: who gets the win?

Aldric Cassata : « It's literally the equivalent of taking a referee who has officiated 10 district-level matches and putting him in a Champions League final, you see. » 1:04:55

Key moments

« I don't see a world where you can't give it to him, but really Alex, I don't see a world where you don't give round two to Reyes. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 32:31

« I completely agree. He's an idiot. There it is, if he ever runs into me, I said it. But even so, Chris Lee, who I consider a good judge, does the job. »

Aldric Cassata · at 32:46

« 150 seconds, Alex, Reyes's life was ruined. 150 seconds. That's insane. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 57:00

« Joe Rogan says I'm annoyed by this guy, what he did tonight is ridiculous, that some commissions have been doing MMA for a long time and others much less so. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:01:54

« It's literally the equivalent of taking a referee who has officiated 10 district-level matches and putting him in a Champions League final, you see. »

Aldric Cassata · at 1:04:55
Page written by the newsroom of Jab Life from the transcript of the show of December 18, 2025. Quotes are those spoken on air, at the indicated timestamp, kept in the original French with a translation. Nothing outside the show is added.
Share WhatsApp X Facebook LinkedIn

Watch next