Skip to content
Aldric & Herbi

Did Gane deserve the win against Ngannou? We revisit the clash!

September 25, 20251:23:1946 707 views on YouTube571 likes
Did Gane deserve the win against Ngannou? We revisit the clash!

Jab Culture re-judges round by round the Ngannou-Gane fight from January 2022 using the official criteria in effect.

Key facts
  • Show : Aldric & Herbi of Jab Life, aired on September 25, 2025, 1:23:19.
  • People discussed : Ciryl Gane, Francis Ngannou, Tom Aspinall, Fernand Lopez, Daniel Cormier, Joe Rogan, Alexander Volkanovski, Manon Fiorot, Khamzat Chimaev, Curtis Blaydes.
  • Topics : MMA judging, UFC heavyweight, Gane vs Ngannou, scoring criteria, effective grappling.
  • Source : transcript of the show, 46 707 views on YouTube.

What is said in the show

Alexandre Herbinet and Aldric Cassata dedicate this episode to a round-by-round re-judgment of the fight between Francis Ngannou and Ciryl Gane (UFC 270, January 22, 2022, Anaheim, California). They start by recalling the context: vacant title, ABC judging criteria in effect since March 2017 in California, and the official scores from the three judges (DK Clerry, Sal D'Amato, Ron McCarthy). They then present fan data from MMA Decision and Verdict, which show a closer fight than the collective unanimity suggests. The detailed round-by-round analysis highlights that positional control without strikes or submission attempts should not count according to the 2016 criteria. Round 1 is judged very close, round 2 is clearly awarded to Gane, round 3 clearly to Ngannou after a spectacular slam, and round 4 remains contested. On round 5, both hosts conclude that Gane, thanks to his striking and submission attempts, should have won it under the criteria in place, which could have earned him the title. The show closes with a brief discussion about the upcoming Gane-Aspinall fight at UFC 321.

Chapters

Key moments

« This fight is genuinely very close to judge. It is much closer than people think, and there are moments where you realise just how much you are influenced by the commentary. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:10

« In 8 minutes 30 of control throughout the entire fight, he lands three significant strikes. Zero submission attempts. How is that effective grappling? »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 56:23

« Ciryl Gane should have won the title that night. Ciryl Gane wins round 5. I am sorry. »

Aldric Cassata · at 59:11

« This collective unanimity is, in fact, complete nonsense because it hides behind control time and lay-and-pray, and that had no place being rewarded. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:11:07

« For me, this is the most beautiful round of Ciryl Gane's career, given the opponent, the context, and what he does. »

Aldric Cassata · at 35:01
Page written by the newsroom of Jab Life from the transcript of the show of September 25, 2025. Quotes are those spoken on air, at the indicated timestamp, kept in the original French with a translation. Nothing outside the show is added.
Share WhatsApp X Facebook LinkedIn

Watch next