Skip to content
Jab Culture

Our ideas to REVOLUTIONIZE MMA scoring - Jab Culture #2

May 28, 202556:219 971 views on YouTube356 likes
Our ideas to REVOLUTIONIZE MMA scoring - Jab Culture #2

Alexandre and Aldric break down MMA scoring and put forward concrete reforms.

Key facts
  • Show : Jab Culture of Jab Life, aired on May 28, 2025, 56:21.
  • People discussed : Manon Fiorot, Valentina Shevchenko, George Saint-Pierre, Ciryl Gane, José Aldo, Merab Dvalishvili, Alexa Grasso, Canelo Álvarez, Dana White.
  • Topics : MMA scoring, professional judges, open scoring, PRIDE FC, 10-point must system, judging reform.
  • Source : transcript of the show, 9 971 views on YouTube.

What is said in the show

Alexandre and Aldric open the debate on the MMA judging system, which they consider ill-suited to the sport. They recall that the 10-point must system, inherited from boxing, is poorly adapted to three-round fights. They discuss the idea of involving the referee as a judge, highlighting his privileged vantage point, before setting the proposal aside due to the excessive pressure it would create. They criticize the lack of professionalization among judges, citing Adalaide Byrd as an example of a boxing judge with no MMA expertise officiating on major cards. They argue for professional judges from an MMA background, trained and traveling with the organizations. They analyze the judging criteria in place since 2016, finding them too vague, and lament that 10-10 and 10-8 scores are almost never used. Pride-style overall judging is examined, along with its advantages and risks. Open scoring is presented as a realistic and immediately applicable reform. In conclusion, they advocate for clearer criteria, open scoring, professional MMA judges by 2027-2028, and a requirement for judges to explain themselves publicly after controversial decisions.

Chapters

  • 0:00Intro
  • 0:58Is MMA well judged under the "10-point must system"?
  • 4:28What if the referee were also a judge, as in boxing in the old days?
  • 10:06MMA-specific judges, really? The Adalaide Byrd example
  • 15:08What if the UFC had its own professional judges?
  • 17:14Should the judging criteria be changed?
  • 25:28Should defense be taken into account?
  • 29:16Do we focus too much on things that don't matter?
  • 31:36Should there be more rounds scored 10-8?
  • 34:30Judging the fight as a whole like in PRIDE -- a good idea?
  • 40:00What if open scoring were the solution?
  • 46:50A 10-minute first round like in PRIDE?
  • 49:23The (different) judging criteria used in PRIDE
  • 52:34Our conclusions and proposals for improving judging

Questions raised in the show

Should there be more rounds scored 10-8?

un intervenant : « I think that the 10-10 round and that significant difference of a 10-8 -- we just never use them. » 32:53

What if open scoring were the solution?

un intervenant : « It's one of the rare sports in the world that works like this. A footballer with 10 minutes left knows the score. A basketball player with 5 minutes left in the fourth quarter knows the score, and the fighter doesn't. » 44:42

Key moments

« Adalaide Byrd has no business judging MMA. She already judges boxing, and she's very borderline in boxing based on what we've seen. She's been judging it for 40 years. But it's not the same sport. »

un intervenant · at 11:53

« It's insane that we don't have judges at the level of this sport today, it's insane that we don't have MMA specialist judges. »

un intervenant · at 12:20

« I think that the 10-10 round and that significant difference of a 10-8 -- we just never use them. »

un intervenant · at 32:53

« It's one of the rare sports in the world that works like this. A footballer with 10 minutes left knows the score. A basketball player with 5 minutes left in the fourth quarter knows the score, and the fighter doesn't. »

un intervenant · at 44:42

« Judges have an obligation to come and explain a decision in front of the media. It should almost be mandatory, because there are too many repercussions on athletes' careers. »

un intervenant · at 54:38
Page written by the newsroom of Jab Life from the transcript of the show of May 28, 2025. Quotes are those spoken on air, at the indicated timestamp, kept in the original French with a translation. Nothing outside the show is added.
Share WhatsApp X Facebook LinkedIn

Watch next