Were Allen-Silva and Silva-Namajunas judged correctly? We redo the fights!

Allen-Silva and Silva-Namajunas revisited round by round to check whether the judges got it right.
- Show : Aldric & Herbi of Jab Life, aired on January 31, 2026, 1:45:43.
- People discussed : Jean Silva, Arnold Allen, Natalia Silva, Rose Namajunas, Arman Tsarukyan, Dan Hooker, Taylor Lapilus, Benoît Saint-Denis, Abdoul Abdouraguimov, Manon Fiorot, Valentina Shevchenko, Fares Ziam, Salahdine Parnasse, Francis Ngannou.
- Topics : MMA judging, UFC 324, we re-scored it, featherweight, women's flyweight.
- Source : transcript of the show, 7 724 views on YouTube.
What is said in the show
For the 32nd episode of Jab Culture, Alexandre Herbinet and Aldric Cassata re-score the two controversial fights from UFC 324. Before the analysis, they correct mistakes made the previous Monday about the refereeing of Benoit Saint-Denis's fight, comment on Patricky Pitbull's release from the UFC, the nose injury Dan Hooker suffered at the hands of Arman Tsarukyan during the face-off, and the first official PFL rankings with Taylor Lapilus in 3rd place. They also discuss Paramount+ viewership figures. On Arnold Allen vs. Jean Silva, after several slow-motion rewatch sessions, they award round 1 to Allen, round 2 to Silva, and round 3 to Silva, concluding on a 29-28 for Silva. Aldric admits he changed his mind since Monday, largely because of a flying knee he thought had landed when watching it live. On Natalia Silva vs. Rose Namajunas, both commentators call the fight a stinker, noting that almost no strike truly connects. Aldric scores round 1 10-10, round 2 to Rose, and round 3 to Silva, concluding a draw, while Alexandre awards all three rounds and concludes 29-28 Silva. Both emphasize how difficult it is to score rounds that are almost entirely empty.
Chapters
- 0:00Intro
- 2:50Corrections + UFC/MMA news
- 18:55Arnold Allen-Jean Silva: we redo the fight
- 25:45Allen-Silva: round 1
- 38:05Allen-Silva: round 2
- 53:45Allen-Silva: round 3
- 59:25Allen-Silva: verdict and thoughts
- 1:01:50Natalia Silva-Rose Namajunas: we redo the fight
- 1:04:00Silva-Namajunas: round 1
- 1:20:05Silva-Namajunas: round 2
- 1:33:15Silva-Namajunas: round 3
- 1:36:40Silva-Namajunas: verdict and thoughts
Key moments
« Not a single media outlet gives it to Arnold Allen. Not one out of 16. Which already puts some perspective on everything we're hearing. »
Alexandre Herbinet · at 23:45
« Everyone who cried scandal over 30-27 -- no, I get it now. There's a world where you score 30-27 in that fight. I don't, but you can. »
Aldric Cassata · at 32:47
« I genuinely think Whitman leaving is the end of Rose's career. It hurt her a lot more than we thought. »
Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:09:35
« It's a stinker. I'll say it plainly, it's a stinker. Even Silva said it at the end of the fight, I didn't have a good fight. Well, it takes two to have a good fight. »
Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:04:37


