Skip to content
Aldric & Herbi

Should Khabib Have Had a Loss? Tibau and His Controversial Fight

November 15, 20251:04:397 600 views on YouTube216 likes
Should Khabib Have Had a Loss? Tibau and His Controversial Fight

Jab Culture re-judges the Khabib-Tibau fight of 2012 using the rules in force at the time.

Key facts
  • Show : Aldric & Herbi of Jab Life, aired on November 15, 2025, 1:04:39.
  • People discussed : Khabib Nurmagomedov, Mohamed Mokaev, Alexandre Pantoja, Anté Delija, Ali Abdelaziz, Hunter Campbell, Islam Makhachev, Nassourdine Imavov, Vincent Dutili, Mick Maynard, Conor McGregor, Justin Gaethje, Benoît Saint-Denis.
  • Topics : fight re-evaluation, MMA rules 2012, Khabib Nurmagomedov, Gleison Tibau, Mohamed Mokaev, sports judging.
  • Source : transcript of the show, 7 600 views on YouTube.

What is said in the show

For its twenty-third episode, Jab Culture opens with an update on the Ante Delija and Waldo Cortes-Acosta case: the director of the Nevada commission acknowledges procedural failures but relies on a rule allowing video replay until the winner is announced. The two hosts then discuss upcoming sanctions for eye pokes, before analyzing Mohamed Mokaev's performance at Brave 100 and debating his potential return to the UFC against Alexandre Pantoja. The show then focuses on the re-evaluation of the Gleison Tibau vs. Khabib Nurmagomedov fight at UFC 148, on July 7, 2012. The rules in force on that date are recalled: striking takes precedence over grappling, effective defense is still a judging criterion, and aggression must be effective to count. Round 1 is judged a draw, round 2 is awarded to Tibau thanks to his clean strikes, and round 3 divides the two hosts. Aldric Cassata concludes with a 29-29 draw, while Alex Herbinet awards the victory to Tibau 30-27.

Chapters

  • 0:00Intro
  • 3:20Update on the Delija case and what is going to change regarding eye pokes
  • 11:55Mokaev, a credible challenger for Pantoja if he returns to the UFC?
  • 20:45Context around the Tibau-Khabib fight
  • 26:35The judges' scores and the fans' scores
  • 28:50The judging criteria of the time: defense counts
  • 32:30Analysis of round 1
  • 44:00Analysis of round 2
  • 53:00Analysis of round 3
  • 1:01:00Our final verdict: who gets the win?

Key moments

« It is July 7, 2012. What I just said is very important. I will come back to it. We are at UFC 148, MGM Grand Arena in Las Vegas. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 20:53

« It is at this annual meeting that they will remove effective defense from the judging criteria. So up until then, effective defense applies, and I brought it back to you, the old rules at the time date back to 2009. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 29:22

« I give it a 29-28 for me. As far as I am concerned, we can go through each criterion if you want. »

Aldric Cassata · at 29:59

« Glayon Tibo deserves his little spot among the guys who stole a round from Kabib, alongside Conor McGregor and Justin Gaethje. In my view, he is the first one to steal a round. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 52:32

« 30-27 Gleison Tibo and Khabib Nurmagomedov should not have finished his career undefeated. »

Alexandre Herbinet · at 1:03:46
Page written by the newsroom of Jab Life from the transcript of the show of November 15, 2025. Quotes are those spoken on air, at the indicated timestamp, kept in the original French with a translation. Nothing outside the show is added.
Share WhatsApp X Facebook LinkedIn

Watch next